Afterclose Research

Intrinsic and extrinsic value

Beginner, lesson 6 of 7. Every premium splits in two. One part is real right now. The other part melts.

By the end you can

  • Split any premium into intrinsic and extrinsic value
  • Explain what happens to extrinsic value by expiration
  • Say why selling usually beats exercising

Premium has two parts

Premium = intrinsic value + extrinsic value

Intrinsic value is what the contract would be worth if you used it this second. A call has it when the stock is above the strike. A put has it when the stock is below the strike. It's never less than zero.

Extrinsic value is everything else. It's what people pay for the time left and the chance of a bigger move. Some traders call it time value.

Split it

XYZ trades at $100. Same expiration throughout.

ContractPremiumIntrinsicExtrinsic
$95 call$6.40$5.00$1.40
$100 call$3.20$0.00$3.20
$105 call$1.30$0.00$1.30
$110 call$0.40$0.00$0.40
$105 put$6.30$5.00$1.30

Hypothetical example, before fees. Prices are made up. Not a real trade or a recommendation.

The $95 call lets you buy at $95 when the stock is at $100. That's $5.00 of real value. The other $1.40 is extrinsic. The $105 put works the same way from the other side.

Notice where extrinsic value peaks: at the money. Out-of-the-money contracts are nothing but extrinsic value.

Extrinsic value goes to zero

By expiration there's no time left to pay for. Whatever's left of the contract is intrinsic value, or nothing.

Buy that $95 call for $640 and let XYZ sit at $100 until the end. The contract finishes worth $5.00, or $500. You lost $140, and the stock never moved against you. That's the extrinsic value melting.

The break-even from lesson 1 says the same thing a different way. $95 + $6.40 = $101.40. XYZ has to rise $1.40 just to pay for the extrinsic value.

Why selling usually beats exercising

Say that $95 call still has time left and it's worth $6.40. Exercise it and you get the $5.00 of intrinsic value. The $1.40 is thrown away. Sell it and you collect both parts, less the spread. That's a big reason most buyers close positions instead of exercising.

The mistake to avoid

Treating an out-of-the-money contract like it has a floor. All of its premium is extrinsic. If the stock doesn't get past the strike, every cent of that goes to zero. There's nothing underneath it.

Before you buy, split the premium. It shows you how much of your money is real value today and how much is a payment for time.

Check yourself

1. XYZ trades at $52. A $50 call costs $3.50. What's the intrinsic value?

2. What's the extrinsic value on that same call?

3. XYZ trades at $52. A $50 put costs $0.90. What's the intrinsic value?

4. What's extrinsic value at expiration?